Naturally, without the “contract,” you would have earned more than if the “contract” had been forced on you as is and without delay.

CONTRACT YEAR WITH UNION CONTRACT WITHOUT UNION CONTRACT
YEAR 1 $29,457.25 $28,090.00
YEAR 2 $30,933.25 $30,899.00
YEAR 3 $32,040.00 $31,358.00
Total earnings during 3 years $92,430.50 $90,347.00
UNION DUES -$2,772.92 $0
$89,657.58 $90,347.00
Based on a person who works directly for the company at 54 hours a week.
Includes pay for holidays.
You could have earned $2,083 more in total during the last 3 years with a “contract.”

But, you would have paid $2,772.92 in dues to the union.